59 Shakespeare Ave, Niagara-on-the-Lake — 1

59 Shakespeare Ave

Niagara-on-the-Lake · Town, ON L0S 1J0

For Sale42d on marketMLS® X12880290
4
2
2000-2500 ft²
None
Detached

Description

Proven Turn-Key Airbnb Investment Fully furnished, professionally managed, and immediately revenue-ready: This 4-bed, pool-equipped gem has delivered consistent short-term rental income with minimal owner involvement. Approaching $200K gross revenue in 2025, consistent occupancy, consistent steady upward trend in revenue and ADR with direct booking upside, controlled costs, and turn-key readiness for cash-flowing retirement/investment use. Located in a premium tourist market, this property outperforms market medians thanks to central location, stylish boho-chic design, and private in-ground pool driving premium rates and 5-star reviews. Slide deck validation available, contact for details, calendars, and comps. Properties like this are a rare find. Key Recent Upgrades & Low-Maintenance Features (Turn-Key Ready) Major Systems: Roof (2014), furnace/components (2019/2023), electrical (2000), plumbing (2008), sump pump + battery backup (2023), new sewage line (2023), whole-home dehumidifier (2024). Exterior/Backyard: Full landscaping revamp (front + back/side), new gravel seating/dining areas, outdoor lighting, BBQ (2025), pool cover (2025), security cameras (2022).Interior: Top-to-bottom repaint, kitchen renovation (new range, stove, sink, dishwasher 2025), refinished hardwood, modernized design, all-new furnishings/décor/artwork. Pool: Saltwater system (professionally managed) This is a plug-and-play profitable asset: Solid Cap Rates and Proven cash flow from day one, strong appreciation potential in one of Ontario's most desirable wine-country/tourist enclaves (walk to Queen Street, Shaw Theatre, wineries, Lake Ontario; 20 min to Falls, 90 min to Toronto). Perfect for Toronto retirees or U.S. snowbirds, enjoy peak seasons personally, then let it generate income during off-periods or travel. High guest appeal, and direct booking upside make it a resilient, high-yield retirement investment. (HST will apply) **INTERBOARD LISTING: CORNERSTONE ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS**

Key Facts

MLS® #

X12880290

Days on market

42

Listed

Feb 27, 2026

Updated

Mar 13, 2026

Tax

$4,534

Size

2000-2500 sqft

Lot

77.65 × 126.85 Feet

Parking

None, 4 Parking

Possession

Aug 31, 2026

Listing History

Buy/Sell history for 59 Shakespeare Ave, Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Date StartDate EndList PricePriceEventListing ID
2026-02-27N/A$1,200,000N/AFor SaleX12880290

Property Details

Property

Property TypeDetached
StyleBacksplit 4
CommunityTown
MunicipalityNiagara-on-the-Lake

Inside

Bedrooms4
Bathrooms2
Bathroom Detail1, 3pc, Main
Bathroom Detail1, 3pc, 3rd
Basement TypeHalf
Kitchens1

Utilities

WaterMunicipal
CoolingCentral Air
Heating TypeForced Air

Building

Size2000-2500 sqft
ConstructionVinyl Siding

Parking

DrivewayPvt Double, Front Yard
Garage TypeNone
Add. Parking4
Total Parking4

Land

SewerSewers
Lot Size77.65 × 126.85 Feet
Lot Size CodeFeet

Additional Details

Year built51-99
FoundationConcrete Block
RoofAsphalt Shingle
FireplaceY
PoolInground
DenY
Family roomY
ExtrasBuilt-in Microwave, Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Stove, Pool Equipment, Washer

Rooms (11)

Kitchen

3.68 × 4.37 m

Dining

3.68 × 5.99 m

Living

4.67 × 5.59 m

Foyer

2.03 × 3.0 m

2nd Br

3.45 × 5.28 m

Den

2.51 × 3.96 m

Bathroom

1.52 × 3.05 m

Comparable Sales

Estimated Market Value

AI Estimated Value
Beta

$1,146,548

Range: $1,047,409 $1,245,686

LowHigh

Estimated by AI based on market data. For informational purposes only.

Mortgage Tools

Mortgage calculator

20%

Monthly Payment

$5,501

  • Down payment$240,000
  • Mortgage amount$960,000
  • Total interest$690,300
  • Total cost$1,890,300

Cash flow analysis

$5,501

Total monthly payment

$5,879

Break-even down payment

100%

Cash flow-$5,879

Location

Similar Active Listings

The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.